Guide reviewing :/

Asmoday dead on again

Personally, I just downvote them. They are not worth the time for anyone to read them, they are not clear and are obvious that the person put no effort into the guide. There are clear and easy chapters that pretty much have everything you could want and need. Makes it pretty much idiot proof to set up the guide. I do not go around downvoting everything and anything. Most of the time if I did not agree with a guide Ill explain why and give no vote at all. If I did like it, or think the guide is great Ill upvote it.

But a blank "guide" is just worthless in my eyes.

You could always say "I will only review your guide if you meet these requirements" and say that they must have description in their guide, certain amount of posts, etc.

i think your reviews will be worth it in the long run for these guides as it can help people improve them dont bother reviewing them if there just plain garbage tbh review the ones that deserve it so you can help them improve there guide

but like tylevian said its all up to you

You might want to wait until the site gets more popular and more numerous and constructive guides appear. It's your choice though, your feedback could really help develop the already existing guides.