Top 5 Voting

Winners

Hi guys, We (me and my judges0 have reached the decision of top 5.
To be honest with you guys, I had problems between choosing one of two god ideas that could enter to TOP 5 but i have reached the decision

Swampmist1142's finalist


Raventhor's finalist


Razemage's Finalist


Razemage's notes


Those are the winner guys, congratz :D
Sorry for those that did not take the top 5, good luck next time ;)

Voting

Now, for all of you (including the winners) if you want your favorite to win the contest, vote for them by writing the scores of the god ideas (from 0-10

BUT, if you want to vote, you must vote for the others too, like what me and my judges did at the first review though comments are not needed

Rules

1. For voting, you MUST be already a member at Smitefire before 20th of September (to avoid smurf)
2. You MUST votes all the god ideas if you want
3. The the contestant still on the run, you MUST NOT edit your god ideas anymore, (though i couldn't make sure, please be honest ;))
4. You could still vote even if you are contestant, judges are allowed to vote as well

Good luck guys, may the best win

Ok here are my votes,

Rama: 9 out of 10
Ullr: 4 out of 10
Houyi: 8
Charon: 6

Trust.

Trust what

I think he's basically saying that doing your own guy is in bad taste M4X ;P

Well he did say that we can vote if we vote for everyone, so yeah. Still, it may not be polite. But it sure is effective!

well, no, but you instantly voted yours high without reasoning on any of them.

We didn't need a reason. Honestly, it doesn't matter, I want to win this therefore I will try to. And I don't mean to sound like a douche-canoe, even though I am.

You voted for yourself? Hmm...

Well, good luck to everyone XD May the best God Idea... win and what not.

Generally, I'd suggest not voting for yourself out of simple sportsmanship, especially as someone who is around on the site very often.

IMO
Houyi 8
Ullr 7
Rama 6
Charon 5
Shakpana 5

Sorry if they're low compared to what you wish, but I'm not trying to simply grade them on a 1-10 scale, but a 1-10 scale comparative to each other. (That is, Charon might very well be an 8, but in respect to the others, I place it as I did)

I think they're all very unique, well thought out, and plausible, I just find some a little more realistic than others, as in the ability to be envisioned in the game in the future, as well as the toolkit being the perfect amount of balanced and efficient. Good luck to all, and I hope the two I chose to have advance aren't received in ill-will :)